Dignita’s Analysis of Risky Job Listings for Ukrainian Refugees in Bulgaria

Author: Dignita FoundationPosted: 3 years ago
Share:

On September 26, 2023, Dignita Foundation organized an event in Sofia on “Preventing Human Trafficking Among Ukrainian Women in Bulgaria,” where an updated Analysis of Risky Job Listings for Ukrainian Refugees – Summer 2023 was presented. The analysis, conducted by Dr. Alexander Gerganov, Chief Assistant at the Center for Empirical Social Research at BAS, aims to enhance the capacity to recognize trafficking risks in job listings targeting Ukrainian refugees in Bulgaria.

Participation from Key Institutions

Representatives from the Ministry of Labor and Social Policy, the Social Assistance Agency, the Employment Agency, the General Labor Inspectorate, the State Agency for Child Protection, the Ministry of the Interior, and other governmental bodies, along with diplomats, NGOs, and international organizations, attended the event. The main objective was to increase institutional capacity to recognize and address trafficking risks within the Ukrainian refugee flow.

Key Findings and Risk Indicators

The analysis reviewed 200 job listings aimed at Ukrainian refugees during the summer—typically the most high-risk period for potential exploitation. All listings were investigated by Ukrainian volunteers using a “mystery shopper” approach. Kamelia Dimitrova, Executive Director of Dignita, commented:

“We found that job descriptions often differed significantly from the actual duties or lacked essential details about the job. In 85% of the suspicious listings reviewed, the job description provided by the contact person did not match what was stated in the job ad.”

The analysis highlights the following primary risk indicators:

  • Discrepancies between the job description in the listing and the actual job duties, or a lack of sufficient information to verify the job description.
  • Absence of information about the application process, or an overly simplified process.
  • Unclear or missing details about whether a contract is offered.

These findings add to previous indicators from an analysis conducted in autumn 2022:

  • Requests for personal details or documents such as a photo, ID, or passport, or a complete lack of requirements for any documentation, including a CV.
  • Lack of information about the employer in the listing.
  • Willingness to accept applicants without the necessary qualifications.

Sector-Specific Risks

The study found a high concentration of job listings in the tourism sector during the summer season, with increased job availability in this area also linked to greater risks for Ukrainian refugees seeking employment. Hospitality and catering positions often require little to no qualification (64% of job listings in the tourism sector), making these roles particularly attractive to refugees seeking seasonal work. While many job listings are legitimate, some carry high risks, concealing potential exploitation.

In the construction sector, it was found that 73% of the 22 job listings identified by volunteers as part of this sector lacked information about the hiring company. This omission makes it difficult for job seekers to assess the legitimacy of these positions, which heightens their vulnerability to exploitation or deceptive practices. When job listings lack transparency about the employer or work conditions, it creates significant potential for labor rights abuses and increased exploitation of applicants.

Recommendations

Dignita recommends that competent institutions closely monitor high-risk sectors, conducting inspections of employers suspected of violations.

“In conclusion, I would like to emphasize that no single organization or institution can ensure the safety and integration of Ukrainian refugees alone. United, focused efforts are essential,” Dimitrova concluded.

The round table was organized under the project of the “Dignita” Foundation “Ukrainian women in Bulgaria – life without the risk of trafficking”, which is implemented with the financial support of Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway under the Active Citizens Bulgaria Fund within the Financial Mechanism of the European Economic Area. The main goal of the project is to prevent human trafficking and various forms of exploitation among Ukrainian refugee women in Bulgaria.

All responsibility for the content of the analysis is borne by the Dignity Foundation and under no circumstances can it be assumed that this document reflects the official opinion of the Financial Mechanism of the European Economic Area and the Operator of the Active Citizens Bulgaria Fund.

Donate