Legal Assistance for a Victim of Human Trafficking at the European Court of Human Rights

The Dignita Foundation is providing legal assistance to D.K., a victim of human trafficking for sexual exploitation, to advocate for her rights before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). The main issue in this case is whether the Bulgarian legal system allows for full compensation for material damages to trafficking victims when the income is derived from paid sexual services. In D.K.’s case, the national court rejected her compensation claim, citing provisions that consider earnings from “immoral activities” as ineligible for legal protection.
D.K.’s Story and the Process of Exploitation
D.K., a resident of a small village in Northwestern Bulgaria, suffers from bipolar disorder and lost her job after working as a seamstress. Seeking stability, she moved in with a man who initially provided her with shelter and financial support. Over time, he convinced her to offer sexual services so they could sustain themselves, managing and controlling all her income. Held in forced exploitation through threats and control over her personal documents, D.K. became a trafficking victim. After months of abuse, she managed to reach the police and escape the situation.
Legal Challenges in the Bulgarian Court
Following her escape, D.K. filed for compensation in the Bulgarian court, claiming 8,000 BGN for non-material damages due to post-traumatic stress and 22,500 BGN for income lost during the nine-month period of exploitation. In 2017, the Bulgarian court sentenced the perpetrator to a 3-year suspended sentence and a fine of 4,000 BGN, requiring him to register as unemployed at the labor office. Compensation for non-material damages of 8,000 BGN was awarded.
However, the claim for material damages was rejected. The court cited Article 329, paragraph 2 of the Bulgarian Penal Code, which states that income from immoral activities does not qualify for legal protection. This provision, dating back to 1968, reflects societal views at that time towards income from paid sexual services.
Appeal to the ECHR and D.K.’s Legal Advocacy
After exhausting all options for appeals within Bulgaria, D.K. filed a complaint with the ECHR, arguing that the Bulgarian legal framework and judicial practices fail to provide adequate protection for trafficking victims, especially when the income derives from sexual services. D.K. contends that Article 329, paragraph 2 of the Penal Code contradicts fundamental rights of trafficking victims, as its outdated provision hinders effective protection. The Council of Europe’s Group of Experts on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings (GRETA), participating as a third party in the case, has also provided examples of international practice supporting the right of trafficking victims to claim lost earnings.
The Bulgarian Government’s Response
In 2021, D.K.’s complaint was communicated to the Bulgarian government for a response. The government’s stance asserts that victims of trafficking are entitled to compensation for all damages, but not when trafficking involves sexual exploitation.
Potential Significance of the ECHR Ruling
The outcome of the case at the ECHR could be crucial for the future of Bulgarian legislation concerning the protection of victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation. A positive ruling would require Bulgaria to reconsider Article 329, paragraph 2 of the Penal Code in alignment with international human rights standards. This could result in the repeal of outdated provisions that prevent trafficking victims from claiming lost income, thereby supporting efforts for their protection and reintegration.
For more information, visit the official ECHR website. D.K. is represented by attorney Natasha Dobreva, with legal assistance funded by the Bulgarian Fund for Women.

Latest News:

Digital Platform for Professional Training on Human Trafficking

Supporting Young People Leaving Alternative Care: Preventing Human Trafficking
